49.6 F
Spokane
Monday, May 12, 2025
HomeCommentaryReview: "Nagasaki" is a 'masterpiece,' tells stories of survivors

Review: “Nagasaki” is a ‘masterpiece,’ tells stories of survivors

Date:

Related stories

Starting fresh, we aim to transplant stronger roots

Aging couple prepares to move homes, reflecting on change, loss, and hope—transplanting flowers and themselves to new soil.

Unbelievable Mount Fuji ordeal mirrors our repeated mistakes

A student rescued from Mount Fuji returned days later and needed saving again — echoing humanity's habit of repeating its mistakes and the need for compassion.

To end homelessness, invest in harm reduction

Homelessness and addiction are deeply linked; compassion, harm reduction and housing are key to lasting recovery and real solutions.

New Pope Leo XIV brings joy, perspective on faith over politics

We have a new pope! May the Holy Spirit guide you, Papa!

Why certainty might be the real enemy of peace

Certainty becomes the enemy of peace when it silences doubt. True peace allows both fear and love to shape understanding.

Our Sponsors

spot_img
spot_img

By Bill Williams

 

[box type=”shadow” align=”aligncenter” class=”” width=”150″]Nagasaki: Life After Nuclear War By Susan Southard Viking, 2015 389 pp, $28.95[/box]

Near the end of World War II American bombers incinerated 64 Japanese cities, but Japan still did not surrender. The United States then dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, killing 200,000 men, women and children.

nagasaki26n-17-webPresident Harry Truman said victory without nuclear weapons would have cost another 1 million American lives. Others have long contended that Japan was ready to surrender before the bombs were dropped.

Author Susan Southard does not try to settle the argument in this absorbing new book, but focuses instead on what became of the thousands of Nagasaki survivors, who were largely forgotten.

The stories of widespread destruction, instant death and gruesome injuries are heartbreaking. In an elementary school, 26 teachers and more than 1,000 students died. The blast “tore off heads and limbs and caused eyes and internal organs to explode.” People wandered through the ruins with skin from their arms hanging to the ground.

Temperatures at the center of the explosion were hotter than the center of the sun. Until John Hersey wrote his 1946 bestseller “Hiroshima,” most Americans were ignorant of the utter devastation and the loss of life inflicted on Japan.

Many survivors were so badly disfigured that they hid in their homes, afraid of how people would react to their grotesque appearance. Over the next several decades, cancer rates skyrocketed. Overwhelming evidence linked cancer and other serious illnesses with radiation from the nuclear bombs, but the U.S. government for years denied the link.

Decades after the nuclear attack some victims, despite serious scars, began to speak in public about the perceived insanity of nuclear proliferation.

Southard weaves into story the stark reality of nuclear armaments. In 1954 the United States tested its first hydrogen bomb, which was almost 700 times more powerful than the Nagasaki atomic bomb. By the end of 1955, the United States had stockpiled more than 3,000 nuclear weapons.

The author does not preach or advocate. Rather, “Nagasaki” is the work of a scrupulous researcher who documents the stories of survivors, many of whom were children when the bomb fell 70 years ago. The book includes more than 80 pages of notes, index and bibliography, plus graphic pictures of bodily scars and widespread destruction.

A total of 190 members of the United Nations have signed the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. Only Israel, India and Pakistan have refused to sign. Anyone who doubts the potential devastation of nuclear war would do well to read this engrossing book.

Southard calls the decision to use nuclear weapons “one of the most controversial wartime acts in history.” Her scrupulous account is a masterpiece of non-fiction writing with stark implications for a world in which several nations, led by the United States and Russia, maintain stockpiles of nuclear weapons.

Bill Williams
Bill Williams
Bill Williams is a freelance writer in Connecticut, and a former editorial writer for The Hartford Courant. He is a member of the National Book Critics Circle. He hosts the Greater Hartford Sangha, a local meditation group. He can be reached at billwaw@comcast.net.

Our Sponsors

spot_img
spot_img
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest


0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
spot_img
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x