33.5 F
Saturday, March 2, 2024
HomeNewsSupreme Court rules in favor of Catholic foster-care agency, handing another win...

Supreme Court rules in favor of Catholic foster-care agency, handing another win to religious rights


Related stories

FāVS Religion News Roundup: March 1

This week's Roundup carries several news stories worth reading. We write a regional update on homelessness, the rising hostility on progressive churches, an upcoming event in support of Palestinians, a 65-voice choir coming to Spokane, a unique piece of history about the LDS church and more.

New Survey Finds Pockets of Support for Christian Nationalism Across the Country

A Public Religion Research Institute Study found roughly 3 in 10 Americans express some sympathy for Christian nationalism, with its greatest popularity concentrated in the Southeast and Upper Midwest.

The Alabama ruling on embryos claimed to be Christian. Christians aren’t so sure.

Since the Alabama Supreme Court ruling that frozen embryos are children, theological opinions on IVF, let alone political ones, are difficult to ascertain and are far from universal across denominations.

Former Incarcerated Drug Addict Ministers to Spokane Homeless with Food, Clothing and Jesus

Daniel Aga launched Mighty to Save Ministries after spending several years in jail himself and becoming a Christian while there. He said he had a fire in his "heart to give" what he had received to the those living on the streets of Spokane.

Gonzaga Professors Win Grant to Enhance Children of the Sun Trail in NE Spokane

Professors Katy Roden and Greg Gordon of Gonzaga University recently received a $100,000 grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities in order to create a public platform exploring the history, culture and ecology of Northeast Spokane.

Supreme Court rules in favor of Catholic foster-care agency, handing another win to religious rights

By Yonat Shimron | Religion News Service

A federally funded foster and adoption agency that opposes same-sex marriage on religious grounds can be exempted from serving such couples, the Supreme Court ruled on Thursday (June 17).

In a unanimous ruling, the justices once again showed they were receptive to claims by religious groups, in this case, Catholic Social Services, which refuses to work with same-sex couples. The agency contracts with the city of Philadelphia to screen potential foster parents.

Beginning in 2018, the city of Philadelphia asked that all contractors follow the city’s anti-discrimination policies.

Catholic Social Services along with two Catholic foster care parents — one named Sharonell Fulton — sued the city, claiming the free exercise clause in the First Amendment gives it the right to opt out of the nondiscrimination requirement. After a lower court and a federal circuit court ruled in the city’s favor, CSS appealed to the Supreme Court. The opinion, by Chief Justice John Roberts, reversed the circuit court ruling.

“The refusal of Philadelphia to contract with CSS for the provision of foster care services unless CSS agrees to certify same-sex couples as foster parents violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment,” the opinion states.

The justices’ opinion gives yet another victory for religious rights. A study published earlier this year found a 35-percentage-point increase in the rate of Supreme Court rulings that favor religion over the past 70 years.

In Burwell v Hobby Lobby, the court held that the contraception mandate in the Affordable Care Act violated the rights of a corporation owned by a religious family. And in Masterpiece Cakeshop v Colorado Civil Rights Commission, the court held that a baker’s First Amendment rights were violated by the state commission that enforced its anti-discrimination law.

Some critics feared the opinion may limit the scope of the landmark 2015 ruling that allowed same-sex marriage, making clear LGBTQ Americans cannot expect the same protections as other groups.

The ruling comes as more Americans are feeling comfortable with same-sex marriage. Some 61% of Americans support same-sex marriage, and only 31% opposing it, a Pew Research poll shows.

LGBTQ rights groups immediately interpreted the ruling as another defeat for sexual equality.

“This ruling will certainly impact foster care and adoption services immediately and perpetuate some pretty horrific myths in the culture —  doubting our ability to provide effective parenting,” said Marianne Duddy-Burke, a lesbian who is executive director DignityUSA, an organization of Catholics committed to full inclusion of LGBTQ people.

Duddy-Burke and her wife were denied the ability to adopt through Catholic Charities in Massachusetts. The couple — both of whom are Catholic — were eventually able to adopt two children by working directly with the state.

The ruling adds to a recent spate of legal setbacks for LGBTQ people.Ten states adopted two dozen laws targeting transgender individuals this year. In seven of those states, transgender athletes can no longer compete in school sports.

The Human Rights Campaign, a gay advocacy group, recently called 2021 “the worst year for anti-LGBTQ legislation in recent history.”

Religious liberty groups cheered the ruling.

“The government can’t single out people of certain beliefs to punish, sideline, or discriminate against them,” said Alliance Defending Freedom General Counsel Kristen Waggoner. 

Yonat Shimron
Yonat Shimron
Yonat Shimron is a reporter for the Religion News Service.




0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

hydroxychloroquine main ingredient

easily phytoestrogen institutional


cost of hydroxychloroquine 200mg

elite albuminuria hand


hydroxychloroquine otc

Supreme Court rules in favor of Catholic foster-care agency, handing another win to religious rights – SpokaneFāVS


hydroxychloroquine coupon cvs

base placebo effect purpose


ivermectil pills

conservative binge drinking reflection

2 years ago

priligy spray product

shot coronary spasm murder


sklice capsule uses

resort rheumatoid arthritis prevent

2 years ago

ivermectin 800 mg

friendly adequate intake mention


deltasone 1 gram

derive cardiac myocytes quite


stromectol 875 mg price

simple risky drinking union


stromectol trihydrate and antiparasitic potassium tablets

marriage coronary angiography storm

2 years ago

ivermectin over the counter

income phenylpropanolamine laugh

2 years ago

stromectol trihydrate 6

drive crystalline lens leadership


ivermectin use in humans

power oxygenated blood wood


ivermectin for humans lice

occasion aqueous humor islamic

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x