65.7 F
Wednesday, June 12, 2024
HomeCommentaryAskAsk A Buddhist: Why are there so many specific rules for monastics?

Ask A Buddhist: Why are there so many specific rules for monastics?


Related stories

Is God a freethinker?

Debating the compatibility of free thinking and religious belief. Is it possible to believe in God and still be a free thinker?

How to protect our votes in the upcoming election

Get insights into the upcoming presidential election and how to protect one's vote from an evangelical Christian's perspective.

WA’s Groundbreaking LGBTQ+ Survey to Amplify Queer Voices of Faith

Read about an LGBTQ+ survey in Washington state, aiming to gather crucial insights into the queer community's demographics, including faith.

Embracing love over hate: Lessons from Spokane’s Pride Parade

Discover the thought-provoking analysis by Sarah Henn Hayward on the protestors at the Pride Parade and the call for love and understanding.

What goes into a hate crime? Don’t assume you know.

Dive into the complex story of a hate crime against Sikh Americans. Explore the details of the case and the complexities of hate in America.

Our Sponsors


What do you want to ask a Buddhist? Fill out the form below or submit your question online.

By Venerable Semkye

Why are there so many and specific rules for Buddhist monastics—227 for males and even more for females?

Thank you for your question. To understand monastic guidelines, it’s helpful to put them in a historical context. During the Buddha’s lifetime there were many different spiritual traditions in India. It was common for spiritual practitioners of that time to leave the home life and wander the countryside, living simply, abiding in rules of conduct and deportment specific to their group, and meditating to gain spiritual realizations. They sought liberation and the end of suffering and believed such a lifestyle would hasten that attainment.

Those practitioners held different views and practiced different methods to achieve their spiritual goals. They respected each other while also challenging each other to philosophical debates in which the one defeated adopted the views and practices of the victor. Lay supporters provided food and other requisites for these groups of wandering renunciants.

Soon after the Buddha began to teach, he attracted a group of devoted followers who were inspired by his teachings and gentle lifestyle. Some of them wanted to follow in the Buddha’s footsteps and requested admission into his community of wandering practitioners. The Buddha admitted them by simply saying, “Come O bhiksu.” This is how the Buddhist monastic tradition began.

Only one guideline was uttered by the Buddha to his monastics during the first 12 years of the community’s existence: “Do not commit any non-virtuous actions, perform only perfect virtuous actions, subdue your mind completely, this is the teaching of the Buddha.” Subsequently, more specific guidelines or precepts were adopted in response to some misbehavior on the part of a monastic.

The order of fully ordained men, or bhiksus, was established first. Later, the order of fully ordained women, or bhikshunis, was formed. They had to follow most of monks’ precepts, as well as precepts that arose due to the misbehavior of a few individual nuns. However bhiksus do not follow the precepts that arose due to the poor conduct of the nuns.

Some of the precepts regard actions that all religions encourage its followers to abandon: killing, stealing, unwise and unkind sexual behavior, and lying. Buddhist monastics also do not take alcohol or recreational drugs. Other precepts concern the relationship with lay supporters, particularly those of the opposite sex. Precepts also regulate behavior towards fellow monastics and things such as personal possessions, robes, alms bowl and deportment.

The monastic precepts were established in a different culture and time period. Some Buddhist monastics choose to keep them literally, others adjust the details of how they follow the precepts to correspond with modern society. But, the purpose remains the same: to make us more mindful of our actions, words, and deeds so that we avoid harming others and do all we can to benefit them. To paraphrase His Holiness the Dalia Lama, “Although our external environment has changed over the centuries especially due to the impact of science and technology, our human minds remain pretty much the same. People from all cultures and all historical periods have the same fundamental wish to be happy and not suffer. They also have the same obscurations that impede attaining this—ignorance, anger and attachment. Therefore abiding in ethical conduct is as important now as it was twenty-six centuries ago when the Buddha was alive.”

As ordained Buddhist monastics, we voluntarily take the precepts because we want to train our minds in virtue. As nuns, having more precepts only makes us more aware and scrupulous in our actions. By practicing virtue and holding precepts that restrain actions of body, speech, and mind, Buddhist monastics contribute to their own and others’ peace and happiness.


Ven. Thubten Semkye
Ven. Thubten Semkye
Ven. Thubten Semkye was Sravasti Abbey's first lay resident. A founder of Friends of Sravasti Abbey, she accepted the position of chairperson to provide the four requisites for the monastic community. Realizing that was a difficult task to do from 350 miles away, she moved to the Abbey in spring 2004. Although she didn’t originally see ordination in her future, after the 2006 Chenrezig retreat when she spent half of her meditation time reflecting on death and impermanence, Ven. Semkye realized that ordaining would be the wisest, most compassionate use of her life. She became the Abbey’s third nun in 2007. See her ordination photos. In 2010 she received bhikshuni ordination at Miao Fa Chan Temple in Taiwan. Ven. Semkye draws on her extensive experience in landscaping and horticulture to manage the Abbey’s forests and gardens.

Our Sponsors

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x